When a snake dancer at Haly's Circus is murdered, James and Leslie investigates suspects. An old psychic approaches James, claiming to have received a message from the dead dancer. James is sceptical, and thinks he is covering up for the killer, who he deduces is the dancer's (and secretly the old psychic's) son Jerome. Jerome (Cameron Monaghan) has a psychotic breakdown and confesses to the murder, claiming to have hated her for her insistent "nagging." Elsewhere, Fish Mooney formulates a plan in order to save herself and the other prisoners when they discover that they were kidnapped so that their organs can be harvested. When costumers begin to steadily decrease at Oswald Cobblepot's newly obtained club, Zsasz gives Cobblepot a brain-washed Butch Gilzean who he says is knowledgeable when it comes to maintaining clubs. Barbara returns to Gotham to discover Ivy Pepper and Selina Kyle in her apartment. Taking advice from the two, Barbara attempts to re-unite with James but is enraged when she sees him kissing Leslie, though neither of them notice her. Bruce holds a board meeting at Wayne Enterprises and voices concern to the executives that the company is involved with criminal activities.
Originally aired 2/16/15
Written by Bruno Heller; directed by Jeffrey Hunt.